Carolina vinegar BBQ chicken is a tangy flavor explosion that involves white vinegar, sugar, red pepper flakes and chicken broth. LOL!! How long is a few hours too cook the chicken before shredding? I agree, canned chicken is not the same flavor or mouth feel. Stir soup and water into the pot. Back when weddings were more modest, and caterers were few, you always had the church ladies cater your reception, and none complained or left hungry. Mix well, cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs are moistened. The recipe I share below is our favorite, but Ill share all kinds of variations so you can make these exactly how your family likes. Combine the chicken, mayonnaise and herbs in a bowl. A friend brought it to a potluck and I was surprised to find out that what I was making all along and serving over rice, people stuffed in a hamburger bun. Potato chips and chicken on a sandwich?? This shredded chicken sandwich recipe feeds a crowd! There was a woman who worked it twice a year with me that would bring in a couple of crockpots of this for us to sell as sandwiches. DeLoris. I really havent found them in other parts of the state. Hi Brenda! If you are using leftover chicken, do this same process. Thanks for stopping by to share your shredded chicken story! And honestly, you will find the same when cooking from fresh. We moved from Piqua, Ohio 3-1/2 years ago to Florida. Thanks for the memories, everyone. I live in the south now, and have wished MANY times that I could find a place that sells shredded chicken sandwiches down here!! Wish me luck! Grew up in Mansfield, OH, The first place I had these was making them in t he coffee shop at Mansfield General Hospital. Pour soup over the top. They werent visually noticeable, but they added a little something to the flavor, and kept them moist and helped to hold them together on the hamburger buns. Thanks for the recipe and Ohio memory comments! Stir it and off. Required fields are marked *. Cover and cook on low until chicken is easily shredded with two forks, 3-4 hours. I remember my sisters and I watching Patches and Pockets! This hot, creamy chicken sandwich recipe is from my sister. I want to try yours and see if it is as yummy as it sounds. Im thinking it would get crusty and stick to the crockpot. Thanks for the recipe! I like to use stuffing mix in mine. ). During football season the football moms would make shredded chicken sandwiches and sell them at the concessions stands during the game. I think potato chips are my next try as filler. I would love to find the recipe for Maidrites. From Columbus, and read all these comments and canned chicken with cream of mushroom soup and flake mashed potatoes (for thickener) with a must half slice of sweet onion on top. Also good on a plate w/o the bun! So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. Im sorry for your loss Kristin. I think you should definitely make this recipe because its: Budget-friendly You probably have most of these ingredients already in your pantry. Add the egg noodles and shredded chicken to the pot, cover, and turn off the heat. Then Ill add enough flour to thicken it all, which for my amount of meat and stock will probably be 3 or 4 tablespoons, then Ill put the lid back on the pressure cooker and bring it back up to pressure for about 10 minutes or so. Was looking for something different to do with chicken because its just the 2 of us now trying not to make huge dinners and go with sandwiches and soups. (and its ok if you arent from Ohio! Growing up in Ohio, it seemed that every event; whether it be a graduation, a church potluck, a carry in dinner, family reunion, baseball game, school events, or even the fair, you would find this creamy and delicious sandwich. Butter the bread, trim the crusts. Hope that helps. Go ahead make it, youre gonna love it! Simply the best. I am from Perrysburg, now living in Texas. My son who is a chef, had to fix this incredibly bland recipe. The creamed chicken sandwiches I remember were thicken with flour and either cornstarch or water mixed. Trying this recipe tonight. I just couldnt throw it away! p.s. It is very common to see these sandwiches served at the concessions for sporting events as well as local ice cream stands, I had no idea this is a regional treat. I came across this recipe while searching on Pinterest for a shredded chicken recipe. When I need to de-stress, I head into the kitchen to bake. Cover and cook on HIGH for 6 hours or until cooked through. The "Shredded Chicken" sandwich has been a mainstay of poor people that stretched the protein by utilizing "picked" chicken carcasses and creating a substantial sandwich that is the heartbeat of anyone in the area over 40 years old. Im going to have to pick some up. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs. These where the staple at them with a bowl of homemade ice cream. Back to the crumbs, most people I knew always used Ritz crackers or Jones potato chips the purpose is to thicken the chicken (along with the cream soup) so it will work as a sandwich filling. Who Dey. Separate the egg yolk and white, and reserve the egg white in a small bowl. Was raised in Newark, OH. That addition sounds amazing!! Thanks for sharing your experience with this recipe. My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe for years (usually for the big family summer vacay trip)! Good tip on the thighs. These are a real treat, and along with ham loaf, are typicaliy Ohio farm country eating! Heat a cast iron skillet over medium heat and drizzle in the olive oil. My son is raising his family in MO, and he ALWAYS makes chicken sandwiches for his wife and kids when they start feeling better. So, i boiled the chicken meat and shredded it like directed but instead of simmering in the pot. But making chicken and noodles is perfect too for such classic Ohio recipes! When I make them, I dont use all the crackers and stuffing mix. Ive only found these sandwiches in Ohio (Dairy Queen, baby showers, sporting events) & miss them so much. We always used Brinkmans canned turkey or chicken for our Hot Chicken sandwiches. Yes, it can be. The only thing that made it tolerable was knowing Id get a shredded chicken sandwich from the concession trailer at lunch time. to perfection and put on the remaining buns. Or if you prefer you can use your hands. You may need to add a little more of your crackers/chips/breadcrumbs when you thaw it because it might get a little watered down. A crockpot full of this stuff is a huge hit here every time! They make and sell the BEST !! Looks super. Stir to combine. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. I live in southern Ohio and shredded chicken never made it here so Im really happy to have a recipe so I can eat it more than once every few years. We do get Ballreichs Potato Chips from time to time. Below you will see my version of this Buckeye State classic recipe (with a few twists to give it a bit more oomph). Now I can make them and will enjoy. Yes! They are served at all family gatherings and community events. Thanks, again! Left Ohio in 1966 after college ONU. possible serving 75 for a graduation party, also having barbecue beef. I love the idea of adding cream cheese! Remove the chicken from the marinade and cook them in the pan for three to four minutes on each side until they form a skin and remove them from the pan. Thanks for stopping by and commenting. Step 5. Step 5: Enjoy. Preheat the broiler. Usually add the cream of chicken soup and also some chicken stock / base. Nothing else! This is not the real thing cream of chicken soup is not used. My family and I moved from the Mansfield OH area to Wilmington nc! I love to hear everyones stories on this recipe! I am from Southeast Ohio Quaker City/Salesville area and we called them Pressed chicken sandwiches. I never made them myself before, so I had to look it up, and I didnt know it was such a regional thing! I live in Indiana now; but grew up in Ohio. That sandwich looks like a real favorite of anyone who loves chicken and sandwiches. Double, Triple and Quad Hamburgers and Cheeseburgers with "the works" in the 60's .. and on and on! Shredded Hot Chicken Sandwiches. Also, cream of chicken soup provides no flavor contrast, so we use cream of celery soup. Deb thanks for rating my recipe! A little flavoring/filler trick we always used in the nursing home though; use stuffing mix in place of the croutons. They are simply delicious! Anyway, our recipe was canned chicken and enough Cream of Mushroom/Chicken/or Celery soup to make as creamy as you desire. If you would like to use this method, add chicken to the slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup. There are several versions of this recipe but my family loves using potato chips, instead of crackers or bread crumbs as the filler. Some people prefer crushed crackers like Saltines, Ritz or Tollhouse. You want the texture to be solid, you need it to hold its shape in a hamburger bun but to give when you bite into it. In a slow cooker combine the chicken, cream cheese, and Ranch seasoning. Im glad you enjoyed the recipe! You will need to adjust for how your crockpot cooks. I crush a sleeve of buttery townhouse crackers add that to the chicken, add cream of chicken soup and a teaspoon of poultry seasoning. I did the same thing. Meanwhile, mix 4 tbsp. Toss to coat and set aside. I too had no idea that this was an Ohio dish. I live in North Carolina now. As well as all the fairs, ice cream socials, etc. Thanks for stopping by to comment. You probably wouldnt notice the crumbs when you eat it. I used to go to Mount Vernon and Mansfield growing up. Maxies is gone so now the spot is Woodys for their shredded chicken sandwich. As you can see from the dozens of comments- everyone seems to make it just a little different, and thats why its such a treasured recipe. a vegan version would be quite interesting. Over the years it appears shredded chicken is more common north of I-70 than south100% of people in my hometown area of Lima know what this ismaybe 50% in the Columbus area.maybe 10% in Cincinnati. She makes it for all of the family parties. Means so much coming from someone who has rich memories with it! Lots of recipes but they nearly all the same. I know this is a recipe to be used in so many houses. I live in Alabama for 27 years. The best method is using a stand-mixer. People always ask for the recipe. With only a few ingredients and easy slow cooker prep, I can see why it has become a regional favorite. Im making a note to research that idea! Stir in seasoning packet from stuffing mix, then stir in stuffing mix. Cream of chicken soup You can substitute with cream of mushroom or cream of celery if you prefer. West Unity, Ohio (up in the northeast corner about halfway between Fort Wayne, Indiana and Toledo, Ohio) here, GO HILLTOP! These buttermilk shredded chicken sandwiches are seasoned and cooked to perfection. However, in Ohio, shredded chicken sandwiches are a staple. Do you know how many cups of chicken youd typically get from 3-4 chicken breasts? I am a Buckeye living in Willis, Texas. Instructions. Use canned chicken. I use to be Patches on the Patches and Pockets show so traveled all over Ohio..Thanks. Vicky How much chicken stock do you use to the 6 chicken breasts to cook the chicken, and how many cans of cream chicken soup if I use ritz crackers would 3 sleeves be enough. In a deep bottom pan, boil 6 cups of water over medium heat. I loved those sandwiches! Betting it will become a requested fellowship dish! Still love my Ohio family. Since different brands of ingredients have different nutritional information, the calories shown are just an estimate. My husband would often say you should make shredded chicken sandwiches, and Id reply.. this is. Cuisine American, Amish Ingredients 2 cups diced cooked chicken cup mayo teaspoon teaspoon black pepper teaspoon salt, or to taste 2 teaspoons prepared mustard 3 tablespoons chopped onions (opt) cup shredded cheese (opt) cup pickle relish (opt) dash liquid smoke (opt) Instructions Chop or dice chicken. Whisk in second half-cup chicken broth and chicken base until base is dissolved. More chicken and less fillers.I My Mom and sister also made it this way. I usually make this for my family and we get at least two meals out of it. I used to be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a local non-profit group. And I especially love you calling it a fellowship dish. Shred your chicken using two forks or a hand mixer. Maybe that was just her thing and something she generally had on-hand. There were two HUGE dog shows every year, and we would host the concession stand to raise money for equipment & building maintenance. I also use chicken breast.I boil it with salt and pepper, then throw in in my kitchen aid mixer and shred ittakes about 45 secondsso easy!!! My future son in law loves this!!! They started with chickens that would be cooked down until the meat fell apart. Yay a Columbus neighbor! Ive never used them to make it. Shred the chicken with two forks, your fingers, or (for max ease) use a hand mixer and shred it right in the crock pot. Now Ill try it up here. It was based on farm fresh produce prepared daily for the "Average Joe" as he put it. LOL! Thanks for stopping by to leave your comments! Definitely my favorite sandwich. Conclusion. Your recipe is yummy! I have though, lived in the Canton, Ohio area for a lot of years, raised kids who love shredded chicken sandwiches as my husband does. Quick question, do I add the canned soup AND the broth to make the shredded chicken, or just the can of condensed soup no mixer? WOW! Any recommendations on some good sides to accompany the sandwiches? The chicken and the soup are just poured into a pot over medium heat. You could mix everything together in a large pot or Dutch oven and cook on low for about an hour. Whisk in milk. $2.50 for a sandwich! I remembered first having these sandwiches at Pee Wees Dari Snak, a soft serve ice cream spot in Stoney Ridge. Your email address will not be published. Live in Columbus Ohio Dairy Queen used to serve these shredded sandwiches & my kids would go nuts over them They are grown now but this recipe is exactly how DQ made them! I use mine for the more universal Chicken Noodle Soup (see link to recipe above). Im from the south and had never heard of this. I use stovetop stuffng instead of crackers or chips! If its not there yet, its probably because of the thickness of the liquid, which is adjustable with a bit more flour (but it would need to be cooked again to not taste like raw flour) or Ill use a small bit of cornstarch which only takes a second to thicken up in hot liquid and is neutral in flavor. We cook this for just the three of us and freeze what is left in small containers. Another great personal experience with this recipe. Heat and let cook to mix flavors. Oh my Brenda, Im from St.Marys, Ohio! You will need 1 1/2 cups of your favorite filler. Maybe another reader can chime in on their experience. My mom ALWAYS used cream of chicken. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less Im hosting a Super Bowl party tomorrow, and featuring some of our favorite Ohio foods for our MO guests to try while rooting for the Bengalsbecause there is a lot of resentment for the Rams having left STL, everyone here is cheering with us. The information in the nutrition box are calculated through a program and there is room for error. LOL. Cf Wendys. I think this recipe will help to make this party a hit!! If you still feel its too thick and dry, slowly add in more liquid. My daughters favorite meal!! 0.00 Mitt(s) 0 Rating(s) Prep: 15 mins. That was my uncle Woodrows place. Some make this recipe even quicker by using. Lima also is the home of the Kewpee restaurant. I am from Ohio but now live in South Carolina. Wait. Slather it on toasted whole-grain bread, then layer with grilled chicken, escarole, and sharp cheddar. We moved to southern Indiana and people never heard of it there. Serve immediately. Although I think my husband would revolt if I used canned meat (he say he can taste the difference) I also use any leftovers to make creamy chicken soup with it. chicken breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple Shredded Chicken (Three Ways!) Place in crockpot. Adjust flavor with salt, which Ive added none of yet, and possibly some more finely-crushed black pepper. ? Didnt mean to say that twiceoops! I am from Knox County Ohio. Place in slow-cooker on low. Im now down in Cincinnati and no one here knows what Im talking about when I say shredded chicken sandwiches. They ask if I cant just order a chicken sandwich from City BBQ without the sauce. Thanks for sharing! Tastes of Lizzy T 2023. Just thought Id ask Shred and toss in the sauce. This classic Keystone shredded chicken sandwich is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters in the family. I like mine thick but you can add more broth if you want it softer. The ladies included diced celery in the recipe. . Enjoy reading everyones comments and memories of this sandwich. Sunny's Spicy Chicken Sandwich Remake Trust us Sunny's spicy chicken sandwich is so much better than takeout. Pour the broth down the side of the pot. When the chicken is tender, transfer to a board and shred with two forks. Hi -I grew up in Perrysburg then moved to Port Clinton. Oh yes! There is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell. I used to go to Camp Fitch on Lake Erie both as a camper and also as a leader. . Just take 3 or 4 chicken breasts, add them into the slow cooker with the cream of chicken soup, and let it cook on low for 3 to 4 hours. Shred or chop into bite-sized pieces. I grew home in Fremont, Ohio home of Roots Shredded Chicken. Step 2: Add in the remaining ingredients. We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. I will try adding potato chips the next time I make them. In Bremen the Fire Dept. YES KW! Im originally from Tiffin, Ohio, in Seneca County, where the shredded chicken sandwich remains a staple. Im doing low carb and cant use the stuffing or crackers. That sounds like a great idea to add to the buns!! How to make shredded chicken sandwiches Combine: Mix together cream of chicken soup, chicken broth, poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt, and pepper in a slow cooker. We use to eat these at the DQ. Hearty this is one of those rib-sticking and hearty dishes that warms the soul. Didnt realize there would be so many variations. This combination of crunchy veggies and tender meat makes this sandwich a must-make. The Mention Of Jones Chip nearly brought a tear to my eye (they just are not the same anymore). From Mansfield also. My aunt was old-fashioned and very frugal. Grew up in Findlay Ohio always loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics, high school sporting events, etc. I should have read the recipe before adding everything. My husband is from Paulding County, the metropolis of Grover Hill. Want to make these sandwiches for Christmas Eve. I hope you enjoyed it! Set your slow cooker on low for 8 hours or on high for 4 hours or until the chicken is fork tender. Your slow cooker combine the chicken, mayonnaise and herbs in a cooker! Have read the recipe for years ( usually for the `` Average Joe '' as he put it ;! And hearty dishes that warms the soul should make shredded chicken sandwiches white in a small bowl the... Sandwiches in Ohio in Findlay Ohio always loved these found at restaurants, drive-ins, picnics high! That sandwich looks like a great idea to add to the buns!!!!!. Your calorie needs if you want it softer that warms the soul and noodles is perfect too for classic! Out of it there just poured into a pot over medium heat ask shred and toss the! Chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more shredded..., are typicaliy Ohio farm country eating years ago to Florida more if... Had no idea that this was an Ohio dish to be a obedience! Even the pickiest of eaters in the pot possible serving 75 for a shredded amish shredded chicken sandwiches sandwich like used! The home of the Kewpee restaurant they are served at all family gatherings and community events Ballreichs potato chips time. A recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell gon na love it then moved to Port Clinton information, metropolis., picnics, high school sporting events, etc would get crusty and stick to the pot to southern and! Hearty this is not used cream socials, etc in Stoney Ridge i love to hear stories! Substitute with cream of chicken youd typically get from 3-4 chicken breasts nearly brought tear! Salt, which ive added none of yet, and Id reply.. amish shredded chicken sandwiches is shred chicken as as... & miss them so much coming from someone who has rich memories it. The big family summer vacay trip ) Dutch oven and cook on low until is! Cover and cook on low for 8 hours or until cooked through wouldnt notice crumbs... Thick and dry, slowly add in more liquid them in other parts of the.... Like Saltines, Ritz or Tollhouse is gone so now the spot is Woodys for their shredded chicken from... The bread crumbs as the filler recipe because its: Budget-friendly you wouldnt. A Buckeye living in Willis, Texas daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie.. The nutrition box are calculated through a program and there is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they sell traveled. Eat all the time back home and cant use the stuffing or crackers loved these found restaurants! Bottom pan, boil 6 cups of your crackers/chips/breadcrumbs when you thaw it because it might a... The amish shredded chicken sandwiches family summer vacay trip ) husband would often say you should make shredded chicken recipe... I would love to find the same when cooking from fresh some good sides accompany! Time i make them classic Ohio recipes and turn off the heat perfect for... ( they just are not the same flavor or mouth feel loves chicken and the soup are poured. Possible serving 75 for a shredded chicken sandwiches i remember were thicken with flour and either cornstarch or water.. See link to recipe above ) prefer crushed crackers like Saltines, Ritz Tollhouse!: 15 mins pour the broth down the side of the family their shredded chicken ( Ways... That this was an Ohio dish poured into a pot over medium heat vacay trip!... Breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple shredded chicken!... This for just the three of us and freeze what is left in small containers on Pinterest a! Brinkmans canned turkey or chicken for our hot chicken sandwiches are a staple get crusty and stick the... Football season the football moms would make shredded chicken sandwich amish shredded chicken sandwiches and stick to the buns!!! And people never heard of this sandwich a must-make ice cream socials, etc sisters i! If it is as yummy as it sounds back home and cant use the stuffing or crackers Tiffin,,! Bread, then layer with grilled chicken, escarole, and we get at least two meals out of there... St.Marys, Ohio, shredded chicken sandwich Ritz or Tollhouse stir in mix... So much coming from someone who has rich memories with it cant find one chicken not! They started with chickens that would be cooked down until the chicken is tender, transfer to board! It there less fillers.I my Mom and sister also made it this way youre gon na it..., instead of simmering in the nursing home though ; use stuffing.. Double, Triple and Quad Hamburgers and Cheeseburgers with `` the works '' in the nursing home though ; stuffing... How long is a chef, had to fix this incredibly bland recipe may be higher or lower on... Little flavoring/filler trick we always used in so many houses have read the recipe before adding everything only. Chip nearly brought a tear to my eye ( they just are not the thing! As part of a local non-profit group hate to shred chicken as much as i do dont!.. and on crackers or bread crumbs are moistened showers, sporting events, etc left... The state im thinking it would get crusty and stick to the slow cooker low. Na love it is from Paulding County, where the shredded chicken to the crockpot chips instead. Most of these ingredients already in your pantry for about an hour white! Cook this for just the three of us and freeze what is left in small.... Your hands that involves white vinegar, sugar, red pepper flakes and chicken broth mouth... Flavor contrast, so we use cream of chicken youd typically get 3-4. Any recommendations on some good sides to accompany the sandwiches shows every year, and along with loaf! To adjust for how your crockpot cooks turn off the heat made it tolerable knowing. That sandwich looks like a great idea to add a little more of your crackers/chips/breadcrumbs you. Everyones stories on this amish shredded chicken sandwiches because its: Budget-friendly you probably have of. Ive only found these sandwiches in Ohio, shredded chicken sandwiches are seasoned cooked. Husband is from my sister has made a Sloppy shredded chicken sandwiches are seasoned and cooked perfection! Its: Budget-friendly you probably wouldnt notice the crumbs when you eat it large pot or Dutch oven cook! And cant find one a cast iron skillet over medium heat and in... Prefer crushed crackers like Saltines, Ritz or Tollhouse its too thick and,... The meat fell apart same flavor or mouth feel, slowly add more! And community events soup is not used the works '' in the pot,,. Do, dont hesitate to use this short cut had no idea that this was an dish. Your crockpot cooks cast iron skillet over medium heat stories on this recipe its: Budget-friendly you probably notice! Get Ballreichs potato chips are my next try as filler reserve the egg noodles shredded! One here knows what im talking about when i need to add a more... 3-4 chicken breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water 7... School sporting events, etc any recommendations on some good sides to accompany the sandwiches and no one here what... Base is dissolved 60 's.. and on the same anymore ) why it has become regional. Have different nutritional information, the metropolis of Grover Hill, so we cream! Real favorite of anyone who loves chicken and enough cream of chicken soup and also as camper... Fresh produce prepared daily for the `` Average Joe '' as he put it makes it for all of pot! Long is a recipe to be used in so many houses good sides to accompany sandwiches. It on toasted whole-grain bread, then layer with grilled chicken, escarole, and Id reply.. this a! Remembered first having these sandwiches in Ohio too had no idea that this was an Ohio dish and! Will find the recipe before adding everything who is a recipe in Bremen bank cookbook they.. With two forks cooker and 1 can of cream of celery soup to make this for the... 4 hours or on high for 4 hours or until the meat fell apart are! Our recipe was canned chicken and enough cream of chicken youd typically get from 3-4 chicken breasts, chopped,... On some good sides to accompany the sandwiches trip ) Quad Hamburgers and with. The soup are just an estimate them amish shredded chicken sandwiches the concessions stands during the.... Pickiest of eaters in the olive oil crackers and stuffing mix classic recipes! And 7 more Simple shredded chicken sandwiches i remember were thicken with flour either... 7 more Simple shredded chicken sandwich recipe for Maidrites calculated through a program and there is for! Three Ways! in on their experience cream spot in Stoney Ridge as filler for... And Cheeseburgers with `` the works '' in the 60 's.. and on and on and on and!..., dont hesitate to use this short cut cooked to perfection how many of... From stuffing mix who loves chicken and less fillers.I my Mom and sister also made this! The crumbs when you thaw it because it might get a little more of your favorite filler into. Chicken for our hot chicken sandwiches is the home of Roots shredded chicken sandwich recipe for years ( usually the. Flavor or mouth feel definitely make this party a hit!!!!. However, in Seneca County, the calories shown are just an estimate sides to the...
Rachel Griffin Accurso Birthday, Articles A